A New Model of Deception

 I tell my history students to consult multiple sources about a topic.  

Not every source you find is necessarily reliable.  There are books and articles that make claims that are so tendentious (“expressing or intending to promote a particular cause or point of view, especially a controversial one.”), and sometimes intentionally dishonest, that they should not be regarded as trustworthy sources. 

 At one time, “African-Americas invented the lightbulb” and “Whites were the result of genetic experiments by a black scientist that escaped the lab” were widely distributed.  Some public schools have taught these in the past to promote Black Pride, rather than teach about African-American scientists who actually did important science. 

 Today, the modern equivalent are books and articles that claim that Islamic contributions to Western Civilization are ignored by textbooks.  No Western Civ textbook that I have read or used fits that description.  (Islamic contributions to math and chemistry have long been recognized.)  Sometimes the claims are more extreme, claiming that much of Western science is Islamic in origin.

 Use at least five sources.  If a claim seems extraordinary search for articles or books about that claim, such as “Ibn al-Naf” “heliocentrism” and see if you find disagreeing articles.  Then try to figure out which is more likely true.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

There Are Limits to This Diversity Idea, You Know

 3/13/23 Campus Reform : Dr. Tabia Lee, faculty director for the Office of Equity, Social Justice, and Multicultural Education at De Anza College, alleges that she is being  terminated  for not adhering to anti-racist “orthodoxy.” Lee, a Black woman who  grew  up in central California, was fired last week from her position as a tenure track Faculty Director for the Office of Equity, Social Justice, and Multicultural Education at the community college in Cupertino, California,  according  to Inside Higher Ed. Among the alleged reasons for Lee’s termination include her objection to the school’s indigenous land acknowledgment statement, successful hosting of a “Jewish Inclusion” event, her reasoned objection to “Latinx” and “Filipinx,” and her questioning of the ideological implications of capitalizing “Black” and lowercasing “White” in the school’s official Educational Master Plan. In particular, Lee’s thoughts on race in America are heterodox ...
Read more

The Stupid is Growing Stronger

  I just received an invitation to  this event : Part 2 of Indigenous Ways of Knowing in Math and Science, a free webinar series presented by The Robertson Program and Kikinoo'amaadawin. About this Event Indigenous land-based teachings, when carried out in collaboration with community Elders or Knowledge Keepers, can provide rich learning experiences for Indigenous and non-Indigenous students. Educators in this session will be provided with ideas and connections in mathematics and science using Indigenous land-based experiences. Learn how to connect these activities to the current curriculum! How gratifying that the Elders or Knowledge Keepers have to be involved.  For some reason, "Knowledge Keeper" makes me think of someone in  1984 . The other dangerous implication is that the methods of learning math and science that work for every other population (regardless of race) is too  difficult  for the indigenous peoples of the world.  Europeans are ...
Read more

Who Knew San Jose State Hired White Supremacists?

   2/15/22 Inside Higher Education : A professor of physical anthropology is  suing  San José State University, saying she’s being retaliated against for her controversial stance on the repatriation of skeletal remains for reburial. In two examples of alleged retaliation, Elizabeth Weiss says she was suddenly removed as curator of the university’s collection of remains, a role she’d held for 17 years, and locked out of the research facility itself. The lawsuit accuses San José State of multiple violations of Weiss’s First Amendment rights.... Most of the bones in question were found in Alameda County, Calif., and range from 500 to 3,000 years old, Weiss said in an interview. They are in the process of being repatriated, but she would like access to them until they’re gone. Weiss, who remains a faculty member, doesn’t know if she’ll ever again see the skeletal X-rays that are part of the university’s collection, either, even though she said these X-rays are not subjec...
Read more